Stop Using AI to Make Your Ads: Where to Get Inspiration & Ideas Instead

5–7 minutes
A person working on a computer in a home office, engaging with a chat interface on the screen displaying an AI partnership advertisement. A fan and various items are visible on the desk.

Seeing businesses use the most blatantly obvious AI images and videos as ads is one of the most annoying and unattractive things I’ve ever seen. And if you’ve felt like that seeing these ads online or on their menus made you want not to buy from their business, that’s normal. And for business owners, companies, and media buyers, there are other ways to make ads more creative and effective without fully relying on AI.

The Lie They’ve Been Feeding You

A few days ago, I got forwarded an email from a business head who is so in love with AI. It was a newsletter claiming you could get a hundred static ads to use in about 40 minutes or less with Claude AI. I skimmed through the email, and all I can say is that the examples, which I’m assuming were already handpicked to be the “best” static examples the author put out, aren’t even that good.

A glass of golden turmeric drink surrounded by various spices like ginger root, cardamom, and black peppercorn, with text listing the ingredients and highlighting their organic nature.

And I know a lot of people are saying that Meta’s Andromeda algorithm favors ad quantity and that producing a lot of ads quickly and letting the algorithm feed them to the right person is the most reliable trend right now. In fact, even Meta Ads Manager itself has AI image generation for different kinds of potential audiences and angles.

But it’s not just about dumping quantity of ads again and again, but rather producing a lot of ads that actually resonate with an audience that exists.

Because if you’re asking me, the audience that falls for and actually converts with AI ads isn’t a big pool of people.

In fact, a lot of ordinary, day-to-day consumers despise AI, and it’s backed up by data.

Marketing Brew at the Cannes Lions Festival of Creativity’s research found that 63% of people are less likely to buy from a company with AI-generated ads, claiming these AI ads look “unauthentic” and make them feel “cringe.”

But I’m Getting Conversions from These Ads

Two things are very likely. One, they are the small pool of people who do not mind, cannot differentiate, or are very happy with the use of AI in ads.

Or two, they are people who would’ve bought from you anyway, regardless of whether they saw the ad or not. And the latter is more likely.

Where to Find Inspiration Instead

I’m sure you’ve heard of software that say just type your website, and the AI will scan it and create tons of ads for you overnight. One of these apps I’ve seen is Holo AI, with outrageous hooks about how they fired their freelance marketing agency and replaced it with AI.

Well, to no one’s surprise, these tools generate the same generic, AI-sounding and AI-looking ads you’ll see anywhere. Instead, here are some places you can look for high-performing ads.

TikTok & Instagram

Simple, short-form vertical videos of just nature or even just people posing or whatever, with some meaningful text, often work the best and do not require a lot of effort.

A collage of humorous and relatable Instagram skits and ad ideas featuring animals, people, and animations.

In both these channels, if your marketing team can do it, you can draw on a lot of trending music to use and skits you can replicate with your product or service. These comedic skits and hooks can make customers and leads engage more with your content.

And if you’re into marketing, I’m sure you know that customers feel like they’re not talking to a brand but rather to a casual person, ensuring your responses stay true to your voice and branding.

Pinterest

Pinterest is the perfect place for surreal, witty, and attention-grabbing static ad designs. Although some of its formats may be outdated and not all formats may work with your business, it can be a great starting point to see what static format design works best with your brand.

A collage of various advertisement ideas including Coca-Cola, DePaul University, and creative poster designs.

You can build your Pinterest feed to show ad designs in your feed. Though be cautious of copying these ad ideas one-to-one, as I see a lot of them are overly used across many, many brands.

Meta Ad Library

Meta Ad Library helps you see what ads certain competitors are running, so it gives you an idea of what ads your industry is running, and you can replicate those with your business’s unique value proposition that differentiates you from your competitors.

Screenshot of Meta Ad Library displaying multiple active ads for monday.com, including video previews and details about the ads' platforms and start dates.

In fact, you can go beyond your industry and see what ads other industries are running, and you can replicate those. Though the only limitation with Meta Ad Library is that you cannot see the performance of these ads. That’s why it’s important to always check and see which ads your competitors keep running, meaning these ads must be working the best for them.

How to Edit or Create the Graphics?

Hire creative people or learn to edit them yourselves. Short-form vertical videos with a text overlay, for example, are some of the easiest ads to do.

Prompting for AI image generation is one of the most controversial skills to have. Though mastering Adobe software, CapCut, Canva, Figma, videography, and other creative skills remains one of the most well-respected fields of work.

You should invest more in people who would think and create the ads for you, just as much as you would believe in and invest in AI ads. AI slop is all around, and people don’t need more.

The Right Blend of AI and Effort

If you will use AI in your creatives, it is okay. But the goal is to use AI-generated elements together with actual editing. Don’t fully rely on AI-generated media, as these will often deter potential customers from interacting with your business. Some good examples of where you can use AI in creatives include:

  1. Creative image shots of your product.
  2. Hyperrealistic human models instead of using stock images.
  3. Vector or simple icons.
  4. Logo and branding inspiration.

If the image looks too AI-generated, then it might be better to just ditch the media. Other than that, I highly advise you to put your own text overlay, logo, and other elements in it.

Final Thoughts

I don’t know why, but these business heads and magnates are treating AI like it’s the solution to all our problems, and those not willing to adapt how they use it are losers falling behind.

While I believe AI has its benefits, I believe you still can’t fully automate some things in businesses, especially the creative side when it comes to ad ideation and drafting briefs on how the ad should look.

What do you think of AI use in online advertising? Share your thoughts below!

COMMENTS

Leave a Reply

MOST POPULAR